Cardinal Czerny urges human accountability for AI in warfare
Vatican News
“Humans must remain directly responsible for any violence and destruction which their technologies unleash,” Cardinal Michael Czerny, SJ, Prefect Emeritus of the Dicastery for Promoting Integral Human Development, said in Sofia on November 17.
Decisions about lethal force, he said, must remain in human hands, and it must always be possible to identify the people who made them.
The Cardinal spoke at a gathering co-hosted by the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences and the Apostolic Nunciature in Bulgaria, where he presented Magnifica humanitas, Pope Leo XIV’s first encyclical, with a particular focus on war and peace.
Cardinal Czerny began with two biblical building projects. At Babel, the builders shared a plan and had the skill to carry it out. Yet their desire to control their own destiny left them scattered and their tower unfinished.
When the people of Jerusalem returned from exile, each family took responsibility for rebuilding one section of the city wall. They trusted in God’s promise, and each family depended on the work of the others.
“The difference between Babel and Jerusalem lies in the desire that guides the act of building,” the Cardinal said.
The same question arises when people design and use artificial intelligence. “What kind of world, what kind of civilization, do these tools help to build?”
Cardinal Czerny warned that the term “just war” is often used loosely to justify aggression, even as weapons have become more destructive.
Pope Leo, he said, upheld “the right to self-defense in the strictest sense” while declaring that the “just war” theory is outdated. The Pope, noted Cardinal Czerny, pointed instead to the possibilities that dialogue, diplomacy, and forgiveness offer for resolving conflicts.
The Cardinal recalled the encyclical’s warning that a culture of power pushes the suffering of people at war into the background as governments pursue strategic interests.
This outlook takes hold when societies come to regard war as inevitable and dismiss those who seek peace through dialogue as unrealistic.
Cardinal Czerny drew attention to three criteria set out by Pope Leo.
First, he said, the chain of responsibility must be “identifiable and verifiable,” from those who design and train a system to those who authorize and use it.
Second, those deciding whether to use lethal force must have time to exercise judgment. Speed and efficiency cannot determine an irreversible decision.
Third, civilians must be distinguished from combatants and protected, along with the infrastructure they need to survive.
For Cardinal Czerny, that responsibility also has a personal dimension. Pope Leo’s call for the “disarmament of heart, mind and life” reaches into ordinary encounters, where the words and images people choose can themselves do harm.
As the Cardinal put it, “the roots of both war and peace are within, and everyone needs to pacify the belligerence at work in each one’s heart.”
Read at the source
This article was originally published on Vatican News